Deck 3/5, 2 of the decks had 43+ cards.
Speed of Deck: 5/10, it seems like Dave just got back into dueling since I've seen some pretty random deck themes and they don't run quite as fast as the new decks.
Procedures: He knew what to do with his decks so I give him a 8/10
Deck build: 6/10 Those cards are so outdated, blizzard dragon, The creator...
Card Knowledge: 6/10 in game 3 he kept activating spell/traps when I had a Bambooshoot on the field which wouldn't allow activation of spell/traps. Other ruling problems occured, but forgot a bit of em -.-;;;;
Flexibility: 8/10 He kept his cool under pressure and didn't seem to respond negatively at all.
Duel Results: 5/10, I won 2 duels out of 3.
41 out of 70, wow you barely made it into Stardust dorm!
I will be here to keep you updated on new decks if you ever need help ^_^